The Story

This morning, I finished Max Hastings, Inferno: the World at War, 1939-45, before I fixed breakfast. What a splendid work it is.

The problem with reading history is that it removes magic from The Story.

Mostly, being in the combat zone involved sitting around.

After the war, the Anglo-American men serving with the Allies were much less likely to physically abuse and/or rape the women they chanced upon.  In those days, many of the Anglo-American soldier-citizens still believed in Bourgeois values of ‘the gentlemen,’ according to Hastings.

This attitude toward “enemy” women was not true of the Russian Army mostly composed of peasant Communists. On the other hand, Uncle Joe Stalin was pragmatic about war.  Cold and ruthless, Stalin offered no quarter, to anyone, which is probably why the Russians defeated the Nazis on the Eastern Front.

Forget all the talk about the French Resistance. With few exceptions, the French, were as anti-Semitic as they had been during the Dreyfus Affair 50 years earlier, and they welcomed the Nazis.  The French shipped their Jews to the camps (as depicted in the New Wave French film, Au Revoir Les Infants, 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Au_revoir_les_enfants

 and more recently in Charlotte Grey).

Only toward the end of the war when it seemed the Allies would prevail, did the French turn on the Nazis. Even then, the policeman, played by Claude Rains in Casablanca, comes closest to the truth of the average French person when he says, “Nothing, I know nothing.”

Among the Europeans, the bravest of the brave were the Poles, many of whom escaped after their little country was crushed, and joined the RAF and other Allied fighting organizations.  After the war, Poland got nothing in return. Governments in the West were afraid of Stalin. And the population back home was not interested tackling the Russians who had destroyed what was left of Eastern Europe after the Nazi invasion. Hastings says, Putin doesn’t fall far from these roots.

                                                           —000—

Some nonfiction is just as bad as fiction.  In fact, some writers suggest that all written material is biased, thus fictional in some way.  However, I learned how to think critically thanks to my Liberal Arts education, and can separate the wheat from the chaff.  You can only learn how to think critically via education, and I hope this recent book on the defining topic of the twentieth century, total war, is required reading for high school kids and beyond.

Most won’t read it, of course, because it takes an attention span that lasts longer than five minutes. Sadly, many kids prefer spin or propaganda (don’t confuse me with the facts) and ignore history at their own peril.

                                                     —000—

Reading history is like gardening.  Until you become an experienced gardener, you don’t realize how many things can go wrong (or right). Parasites and diseases, as well as varmints galore attack your cherished plants. Too much or too little rain can wreck everything.  The gardener must work to remove invasive weeds.  But when you win it’s everything.

Gardening for years until you become experienced and appreciative of a fine garden teaches you to love small things.  This morning, for example, I rejoiced at the sight of a few tulips poking through the soil.  Those few missed by the hungry voles, who ate the other bulbs this winter. Gardening is forever, like the poppies in Flanders Field, a battleground from a long ago forgotten war.

                                                         —000—

Tulips from several years ago

Tulips from several years ago

 

21 thoughts on “The Story

  1. My Grandad is being taken to France on his birthday at the end of March, he has a deep love of history and that particular part of history I must remember to recommend the book to him.
    Thank you for your supportive messages on fb too I do always read them 🙂

    Like

  2. War is depressing, needless to say. When will mankind learn from their mistakes? Look at what is happening now to our world. Love your pretty pictures. Keep them coming. Going with David to see Cinderella today. Hope it cheers me up.

    Like

    • Sounds very different from what we’ve been told, doesn’t it? However, Paris was spared the bombing London received, and there was a good reason for that, the French caved in rather than fight..

      Some French were real heroes, like Marc Bloc the Annals historian who was shot by the Nazis for his work with the Resistance, but many French collaborated with the Nazis and joined the Vichy Government which was working for the Nazis.

      In 1944 when the French realized the Nazis would lose the war, they professed allegiance to the Allies. After the war, many collaborators were murdered by their fellow French. Today the progeny of Nazi men and French women are shunned for their parentage. Also the Neo-Nazi right wing is quite strong in France (and other places too).

      I was shocked by the number of concentration camps in France and the numbers of Jews shipped to the death camps. I believe my kids visited a memorial and museum in Paris dedicated to these Jews.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. My mother tells me that the front line Russian soldiers that came into Korea after the war were brutal savages who raped women who had just given birth, etc. They killed, raped and plundered. Mom wondered how she could have been mistaken in her thoughts about Russians from all the books she’d read by Tolstoy, Dostoyevsky, Chekov, etc. The second wave were kinder and more honorable but they were too frightened of any Russians by then.

    Like

  4. Well it’s not just kids who lack an attention span that lasts longer than five minutes, or who prefer spin and propaganda to sometimes difficult and confusing facts. Anyway, thanks for the recommendation — I just placed a hold on the book at my library.

    Like

  5. To me, World War II is the defining event in the history of man. If such a monumental and global event can be called a microcosm, it is, of every racist, opportunistic, vengeful and power hungry urge than resides in the human psyche, before or since.

    Like

  6. Hastings’ work sounds like an excellent history. A German relative who served in the army in WWII believed the British soldiers were much better disciplined than the Americans in their encounters with civilian women and others. He attributed that to better control by the Brit officers. I’ve not seen anything about that distinction of the limited number of WWII histories I’ve read.

    Like

  7. Technology has decreased my attention span even at my age, but I am fighting back, forcing myself to read (although on an ipad 🙂 ) and enjoy other activities away from the computer. I love your tulip photo. So ready for sunshine and springtime!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s